Monday, May 19, 2014

Ishtar ≠ Easter: Stop Getting your History from Internet Memes Richard Dawkins

The source of my annoyance today: The Richard Dawkins Foundation Facebook page.  Here’s a meme I wouldn’t mind if I never saw again.  (Thank’s Richard for exposing it to over 75,000 people and contributing to its being shared by 195,000.)


First, let’s review why this piece of puerility has zero correspondence with historical reality. Second, I have a brief sermon to those in the Hebrew Roots movement who most often spread this nonsense:

1)   Is the name Ishtar pronounced Easter?  No.  Here are the vocalizations of the goddess collected from the primary texts within the Brill Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible:

If Easter isn’t a Semitic word what is its etymology?  The answer is Proto-Germanic (if you buy Bede’s highly problematic explanation) or more likely Latin. (Sorry if that bores you.)

2) Are bunnies and eggs symbols of Ishtar?  Nope.  Her primary symbol in the iconography is Venus.  When I recently visited the Oriental Institute, I photographed this image of a lion representing the goddess from the Ishtar Gate.


The lion is one of her most commonly associated symbols from the third-millennium onwards.  The two objects in her hands in the meme are probably a symbol of a ruler and a rope—ANE icons of sovereignty.  There is also a famous Gilgamesh passage that associates her lovers with lions, steeds, a certain variegated bird, and shepherds.  I have never seen an image or text which associates her with bunnies or eggs.  Those symbols have different historical origins.  As a side note, I suppose one could argue the “grass of life” utilized to revive Ishtar’s corpse in the underworld by the fly-like kurgarru and kalaturru might be an etiological candidate for that plastic Easter grass that stops up your vacuum cleaner belt…Perhaps this could be a good thesis for Acharya S.’ next book. (Just make sure I get credit for first thinking of it.)

3) Was Easter a pagan holiday that was Christianized?  The reality is much more boring.  Easter was a development out of the Jewish Passover festival.  To be sure, pagan and secular elements were added, but these were prior additions to the existing holiday and not the origin of the holiday as Gene Vieth of Patrick Henry College mentions here.

The meme claims that Constantine (*groan* Why does Constantine always have to be the deus ex machina of every Christian conspiracy theory?) invented Easter as a Christian holiday.  This is dalse considering the Roman bishop Victor was already riling up arguments over the two diverging dates of Easter in the late 2nd century (cf. Eusebius, Church History 5.23.3).  How exactly did Constantine invent Easter if Christians were already arguing about its proper celebration date over a century before he was born?

A word to the Hebrew roots movement:

Does it really make sense to argue that Christians should not make use of symbols with pagan origins or associations when Christians are either: a) totally unaware of a symbol’s history, or b) using the symbol with no pagan (or completely different) intentions?  My problem with the Hebrew roots movement is that the standard of purity it uses to beat up Christian holidays and symbols cannot even be applied to the Bible.  I’ll give you some examples:

John uses a snake as a symbol for Jesus (John 3:14); it is well known that many of the Biblical proverbs have Egyptian origins and influences (If you don’t believe this you simply haven’t ever picked up an academic commentary on Proverbs.); psalm 104 is very reminiscent of an earlier hymn to Aten; psalm 29 seems to be modeled after Baal texts (for example); both Jesus and YHWH are given the Baal’s deity title “cloud-rider” in both testaments. (Here’s an M.A. Thesis on this); or consider that the book of Revelation is crawling with Greco-Roman astrology. (Ever read Revelation 12?)

What examples like these show is that symbols are not magically evil.  John uses a snake to represent Jesus and it’s totally kosher in his mind.  We talk about Jesus “riding on the clouds” and it’s not an issue that this was a title that originally belonged to Baal.  The history of a symbol or its uses in pagan contexts doesn’t make it evil or unusable by Christians, it’s the intention behind the symbol that makes it good or bad.

18 comments:

  1. The Burney relief does not likely show Ishtar. the owls and owls' feet are out of place for her. More likely Lilitu.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope. The scholarly consensus is that it is Ishtar in her killili form. Lions are not associated with Lilitu and very often demon images do not survive as they were destroyed in rituals.

      T.Jacobsen's figurative language should clear up why it is mostly likely Ishtar for you.

      Delete
    2. Hi everyone I'm Olivia Hannah and am here to share the wonderful work Dr Raypower did for me. After 5 years in marriage with my husband with 2 kids, my husband started acting weird and going out with other ladies and showed me cold love, on several occasions he threatens to divorce me if I dare question him about his affair with other ladies, I was totally devastated and confused until a old friend of mine told me about a spell caster on the internet called Dr. Raypower who help people with relationship and marriage problem by the powers of love spells, at first I doubted if such thing ever exists but decided to give it a try, when I contact him, he helped me cast a love spell and within 48hours my husband came back to me and started apologizing, now he has stopped going out with other ladies and his with me for good and for real. Contact this great love spell caster for your relationship or marriage problem to be solved today via email: urgentspellcast@gmail.com or Call or WhatsApp: +14243308109.

      Read more about him on his website: http://urgentspellcast.website2.me/ and Blogs: https://urgentspellcast.blogspot.com/






      Hi everyone I'm Olivia Hannah and am here to share the wonderful work Dr Raypower did for me. After 5 years in marriage with my husband with 2 kids, my husband started acting weird and going out with other ladies and showed me cold love, on several occasions he threatens to divorce me if I dare question him about his affair with other ladies, I was totally devastated and confused until a old friend of mine told me about a spell caster on the internet called Dr. Raypower who help people with relationship and marriage problem by the powers of love spells, at first I doubted if such thing ever exists but decided to give it a try, when I contact him, he helped me cast a love spell and within 48hours my husband came back to me and started apologizing, now he has stopped going out with other ladies and his with me for good and for real. Contact this great love spell caster for your relationship or marriage problem to be solved today via email: urgentspellcast@gmail.com or Call or WhatsApp: +14243308109.

      Read more about him on his website: http://urgentspellcast.website2.me/ and Blogs: https://urgentspellcast.blogspot.com/

      Delete
    3. A POWERFUL LOVE SPELL CASTER Dr,Abaka HE SPECIALIZES IN RESTORING BROKEN MARRIAGES CONTACT HIM DIRECTLY ON HIS EMAIL OR WEBSITE (Https://drabakaspelltemple.blogspot.com direct address drabakaspelltemple@gmail.com)..What else can i say rather than to thank Dr, Abaka who God used to reunite my marriage. Each day of my life, i ask God to bless Dr,Abaka for he has made my life complete by bringing back my wife to me and for this reason, i made a vow to my self that i will testify on the internet to let the world know that Dr, Abaka is a God on Earth. My wife and i had a fight for three days which led to our divorce. On this faithful day, i came across a testimony of how Dr,Abaka helped a lady in getting back her lover. So, i contacted him and explained to him and he told me that my days of sorrows are over that my wife will come back to me within 48 hours for he's going to prepare a spell for me. Could you believe it, my wife came home begging that she needs me back. Do you need any kind of help? Contact; (drabakaspelltemple@gmail.com) OR call his phone number via +2349063230051.

      Delete
  2. So how and why did the fertility symbols such as the egg and the rabbit get involved with Easter?
    also, why should Christians celebrate Easter on a specific date if it was not mentioned in the Bible?


    Regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It seems Christians ought to have the freedom in Christ to celebrate the day of the resurrection if they wish regardless of its being established as a "holiday" in scripture. The early church took calculating the date of Easter very seriously and invested a tremendous amount of debate in the subject. Here's a couple academic articles on that: http://drmsh.com/2014/04/18/calculating-and-fixing-the-date-of-easter/

      As for bunnies and eggs, as far as I'm aware their origins are unknown due to the expansive use of these symbols throughout history, especially eggs. It is very possible it stems from the "red egg" miracle tradition of Mary Magdalene in early Christian tradition. The bunny had some association with the regeneration of spring--easily connected to pagan constructs, but equally easy to sever from pagan constructs and simply take as a metaphor.

      Here's an illustration: Because we moderns use symbols of arrow-pierced hearts on Valentines this does not mean in anyway that anyone takes the Greek gods seriously anymore of that it is a form of secret worship to the gods. The metaphor is able to be retained without allegiances to their pagan religious sources.

      Delete
  3. It's like you watch a bunch of William Lane Craig debates and come up with your strategy. You put the burden of proof on those arguing against you, even though your religion doesn't make sense. Like how you put the burden of proof on the post put up by the Richard Dawkins foundation, but then didn't provide proof for your own answer of the holiday's origin. You still haven't even provided evidence of Jesus being mentions by historians during the time he supposedly lived. You still haven't provided evidence that Jesus was God in the flesh. What about those miracles? Do you believe them? No "miracle" has passed the scientific test.

    Different origins for Easter are given, which makes sense because the origins of the holiday would be hard to trace. The fact is that dependable sources don't give the holiday Christian, or Jewish origins. Of course we are largely talking about semantics. It's just like how we know that American Football originates from older forms of Football, even though it is a different sport. Easter may be a different holiday from numerous spring equinox celebrations that pre date Christianity, but it still has it's roots in many of those rituals. For the most part Easter didn't originate from Passover, and Passover didn't originate from God passing over the Israelites in Egypt so he could kill Egyptian first born children.

    http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/anthropology-in-practice/2013/03/31/beyond-ishtar-the-tradition-of-eggs-at-easter/

    http://books.google.com/books?id=yFsw-Vaup6sC&pg=PA53&dq=Eosturmonath+%22English+months%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ceD2U4feF4SL7Aat7oAI&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Eosturmonath%20%22English%20months%22&f=false

    http://atheism.about.com/od/easterholidayseason/p/PaganChristian.htm

    http://www.religionfacts.com/christianity/holidays/easter.htm

    http://www.snopes.com/holidays/easter/easterlore.asp

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your first source supports everything I've said here. I don't disagree with any of it. Your second is a reference to Bede who is the source of one of the possible etymologies I mentioned in this post. The remaining three I don't care to read because they are internet encyclopedias--one archon away from Yahoo answers. I also don't disagree with the bit you've said about Easter traditions having pagan roots either. I don't understand how any of this is relevant to the actual content of my post.

      Delete
    2. I'm confused. Has William Lane Craig been discredited as an historian? Are his peer-reviewed writings, and those of the other sources the author mentions, somehow inferior to the un-reviewed, inch-deep writings of popular culture sites like Snopes and religionfacts? Why not cite Zeitgeist if you are determined to win an argument regardless of the reliability of your sources?

      Delete
    3. Lew GR10 Atheists often focus on this supposed "lack of evidence" that Jesus existed. Despite many of the documents that witnessed his existence. The irony is the proofs that we do have are from those who criticised him. The Jewish Talmud documents his existence with reference to him "boiling in excrement" along with his "whore of a mother." If that isn't proof enough for you, I do not know what will be.

      The fact remains...that those who conquer...write the history, or re-write the history.

      Delete
    4. howabout... none of you have the answer to anything and everyone is wrong including me so we can shut up and move on instead of debating the ancient symbols of meaningless lies meant to control each other in a "my religion is better than yours" kind of way, which is how most of human history has been existing for thousands of years and up to this day...

      Delete
  4. The prehistoric mind,eg, Stonehenge like cultures, equated the Sun with the heat of females when in estrus. Estrus becomes "East", then Easter, where the sun rises & gets warmer in the Spring as animals start to propagate. In order for the Roman Empire to gain control over pagans their religious holidays were adapted to the new definitions brought about by Christ's advent & adoption by Rome as the state religion. Easter varies because of its need to conform to the pagan system of religious sun worship.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The prehistoric mind,eg, Stonehenge like cultures, equated the Sun with the heat of females when in estrus. Estrus becomes "East", then Easter, where the sun rises & gets warmer in the Spring as animals start to propagate. In order for the Roman Empire to gain control over pagans their religious holidays were adapted to the new definitions brought about by Christ's advent & adoption by Rome as the state religion. Easter varies because of its need to conform to the pagan system of religious sun worship.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi everyone I'm Olivia Hannah and am here to share the wonderful work Dr Raypower did for me. After 5 years in marriage with my husband with 2 kids, my husband started acting weird and going out with other ladies and showed me cold love, on several occasions he threatens to divorce me if I dare question him about his affair with other ladies, I was totally devastated and confused until a old friend of mine told me about a spell caster on the internet called Dr. Raypower who help people with relationship and marriage problem by the powers of love spells, at first I doubted if such thing ever exists but decided to give it a try, when I contact him, he helped me cast a love spell and within 48hours my husband came back to me and started apologizing, now he has stopped going out with other ladies and his with me for good and for real. Contact this great love spell caster for your relationship or marriage problem to be solved today via email: urgentspellcast@gmail.com or Call or WhatsApp: +14243308109.

    Read more about him on his website: http://urgentspellcast.website2.me/ and Blogs: https://urgentspellcast.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. BEST ONLINE LOVE SPELL CASTER TO GET YOUR EX LOVER, HUSBAND, WIFE, GIRLFRIEND OR BOYFRIEND BACK. ADD HIM UP ON WHATSAPP: +2349066410185

    Hello my respectable viewers and i'm from (FLORIDA, UNITED STATE) I am very happy to share this amazing testimony, i was hurt and heart broken when my husband left me with our kid, i was confused and didn't know what to do, i loved him so much, i tried all i could to bring him back but all my effort was in vain , on one faithful day i explained my problem to my friend, and she told me of a great love spell caster called "dr gbojie" whom also make her pregnant when she was looking for a child, i never believed in spells but i have give a try to see if things will get better, i contacted DR gbojie through the contact info my friend gave to me, after some hours the spell caster responded to me he told me to stay and gave me some instructions on what to do and i did exactly as i was told, to my greatest surprise, my husband who has not called me for a very 3 yrs , called me and start apologizing for all the wrongs he did to me and pleaded with me that he want to return home with me and the kids, now he loved me more than ever before, my respectable viewers brothers and sisters if you are passing through any kind of problem contact him and i give you 100% guarantee that he will solve your problems. this is his contacts: GBOJIESPIRITUALTEMPLE@yahoo.com or GBOJIESPIRITUALTEMPLE@gmail.com add him up on whatsApp at: +2349066410185 .or check out his website :http://gbojiespiritualtemple.website2.me

    ReplyDelete
  8. Real spell caster to bring your ex lover back and save your marriage (Oguguspellcaster@gmail.com /Whatsapp+2348081594908)

    My Name is Jack Robb from USA, I want to say thank you to Dr Ogugu for the good thing he has done for me,Though am not sure if this is the best forum to show my joy and happiness for what he has done for me but i cant hide my happiness and my Joy so i have to share it with people, my marriage got crashed about two years ago and i tried all i could within my power but to no avail. i saw post and testimonial about the good things Dr Ogugu has been doing so i decided to give it a try. though he is always a busy man but when he responded back to my email, he gave me 48hours for my marriage to be restored really just like he said my marriage was restored since then I am happy and i am living happily i am so grateful, Dr.Ogugu you can always email him here: Oguguspellcaster@gmail.com or call his phone/Whatsapp+2348081594908

    ReplyDelete